For the past few years Jimmy Kimmel has lit up our TVs and computers like a pre-smashed Jack O’Lantern with his “I Told My Kid I Ate All Their Halloween Candy” prank. Every year he challenges parents to trick their kids into believing they ate all their candy and film it so that Jimmy can compile the best ones and allow us to laugh at the tears of children. We won’t be able to see this year’s crop until next week but we are able to look back on past compilations because the Internet has everything.

Put the kids to bed early and start chowing down on their candy while you watch tonight’s ALL-NEW Jimmy Kimmel Live Special Halloween Show at 11:35ep featuring Andy Samberg, Rosie Perez and music from The Flaming Lips!